Requiem for Cygnus Destroyer, LJN Defender and IUPG March 6, 2021

10/5/23 UPDATE: Two comments came in since the June updates, which I will edit for brevity. The first was from Liz on September 9: “Matthew S’s comment made me laugh my ass off. … Kinda seems like a rude thing to claim you enjoyed somebody’s work and then just disregard their identity because of ‘SJWs’ … If some of the old fans are worried about weirdo conspiracy theories from the days of the Harlem Shake, then I don’t blame them from trying to distance themselves from us. However, I do also miss their content and I tried checking their X account as I wondered what they were up to and boom, it’s not there anymore … I tried searching up ‘Sapphic Sorceress’ and I do not think Morgan is going by that name. I hope that Morgan decides to bring back the series someday seeing as how LGBTQ friendly/identifying gaming channels are now way more accepted today … I’m just hoping they’re doing alright.” The second comment came today from Brandon M.: “Found my way here after YouTube started recommending reuploads of The LJN Defender to me and I went to figure out why the originals were gone. It’s kinda painful that this is the only explanation I could find and it’s marred by calling their new (well, three years old at this point) identity an SJW phase. I do appreciate that you’re trying to be respectful though, Mike. Wishing the best for Morgan. You can truly only make videos defending disliked games for so long, but I hope they know they’d be welcomed if they ever decided to mingle in retro gaming spaces again.” The reuploads can be found on The Slums Archive YouTube channel.

6/25/23 UPDATE: I learned yesterday that videos were posted to Archive.org back in December. I’ll leave it to the reader to seek out the page with the videos. (6/27: Or check the comments.)

5/24/23 UPDATE: I hoped this would never happen, but the same Matthew in the prior updates told me this: “Unfortunately, it appears Matt has deleted all his YT channels permanently. No more LJN Defender.” So, I said, “That’s terrible. Well, I’ll leave this post up for posterity, but update to reflect the deleted videos. Apparently, nothing is forever.” I fear I may be forced to take this post down altogether before long, but until then, it stays.

8/17/22 UPDATE: Again, from Matthew S.: “Hi, just a quick update on Matt’s channel… a change happened. Quite minor, but hey, it’s something. His Mx. Morgan Enby channel has now been renamed ‘Sapphic Sorceress.’ So seems like Matt is still embracing Enby philosophy, but given a lack of any updates or content for several years from now, I suppose it’s possible we may see something soon? [J]ust to clarify, I do not know Matt personally, however I’ve been following him since 2014. But I have read all his Disqus content and Morgan was just his internet handle/alias since 2020, so I would imagine given the lack of anything from that particular name anywhere, Matt is trying to distance himself from his former fanbase, likely to avoid the pressure/discussion of returning to videogame content. Just a quick update, nothing really substantial but its good to at least see SOMETHING. Thanks again Mike.” Thank you again, Matthew, whose initial comment is below.

7/30/22 UPDATE: I received this comment today from Matthew S.: “Morgan was Matt’s Reddit alias online at the time, but he never legally changed his name or did any kind of transition. He still lives in Peru, NY to this day in his childhood home as far as I can see, with his mother. I honestly think this is just another phase. Matt spent endless hours in his room, playing and recording games/videos for his YT channel. I think the SJW phase is just something else he fell into, as you can see BLM and LGBTQ stuff on the front of his home’s window as of 2021. I miss him greatly, he was a video editing genius and had an incredible natural sense of humor depicted in his early videos, even if it was just scripted.” I thanked Matthew for the clarification and said I miss Matt, too. The original update to the original post is below.

3/31/21 UPDATE: A comment from Greg B. noted that “Matt is now Mx. Morgan Constance Enby. [They] abandoned video game talk all together … focusing on Trans Rights/Awareness and Politics.” As I stated in my reply, thank you, Greg, for letting me know. I sincerely wish them luck in their current endeavor. If any readers share their political views and are equally active, you can follow them on Twitter. (It’s the same account as before, but with a new link. That’s why I couldn’t find it.)

Read the original post below.

In June 2017, I discovered a video game-centered YouTube channel run by the enthusiastic Matt Ezero (“ezzer-o”), who bears a striking resemblance to actor and director David Hyde Pierce. Matt had three series running concurrently:

1. Cygnus Destroyer’s Retro Reviews – the channel’s original concept, reviewing retro video games and consoles that Matt grew up playing or recently acquired
2. The LJN Defender – an alternate take on video games published by LJN, a company that incurred the wrath of The Angry Video Game Nerd, one of Matt’s influences
3. Innocent Until Proven Guilty (IUPG) – a balanced look at flawed video games to determine whether they are innocent or guilty (or on rare occasions, guinnocent)

I had nearly five years of content to catch up on. There wasn’t much I didn’t like. Here are the first five videos I saw upon my discovery:

My only pet peeve was the unscripted status update outros, but Matt’s transparency was admirable. He had eschewed those outros a year before I discovered the channel. He had also upgraded his game capture methods from composite for pre-HD consoles to RGB and HDMI shortly before my discovery, starting with Michael Jackson’s Moonwalker:

Naturally, I became a loyal subscriber, and when Matt started a Patreon account in 2018, I was a proud pledge.

The content kept on coming, and as a patron, I provided feedback and voted on upcoming topics. Best of all, my name was featured in the credits. For example, Sonic and the Black Knight:

Incidentally, the Wiimote/nunchuk control demonstration in that video was hilarious: “Looks fun, doesn’t it?!” I love absurd humor.

Another example, Zelda CD-i games:

My Patreon post comments were even seen in the background. This was at the end of the Simon’s Quest video:

…and Matt’s tribute to the Sega Master System:

Unfortunately, any videos he posted to Patreon – mostly episode commentaries – were unscripted, which meant small things, like repeat phrases (i.e. “so…yeah,” “kind of”) or vocal quirks, got on my nerves. Not only that, but his persona was radically different. Main channel Matt was lively; Patreon Matt was staid. (He was also a political progressive who “liked” left-wing political posts on Twitter, but his tweets were apolitical.) I wasn’t expecting the same intense personality as the videos, but it was quite a contrast, akin to the chill energy of some Twitch streamers. And that was fine.

I think the reason phrases and quirks irk me is because I worked hard to improve my speech, or at least improve my presentation in a public forum. Hearing others speak how I used to, and still do to some extent in unguarded conversations, on recorded media is unnerving. I’m such a perfectionist that I edited all the fumfering and misspeaking out of old home audio recordings (late teens, early 20s) of play-by-play of my friends bowling at nearby AMF Wantagh Lanes.

With that said, though – to use one of his phrases – I gained insight into how he made his videos. For example, overhead camera shots of him playing Nintendo Switch games in handheld mode (as in this video) were actually recorded straight ahead with an upside down perspective. He would flip the video in Vegas Pro, his video editing software of choice, so that the view was right side up.

I also had the opportunity to vote in polls to determine episode topics. Among my votes was for an IUPG on Animal Crossing: amiibo Festival.

As 2019 progressed, Matt began to experience creative burnout. To counter that, he tried an experimental unscripted video on Bubsy: Paws on Fire. My black and white, all or nothing brain figured this was the way things would be from now on. So, I unpledged and unsubscribed. YouTube recommendations pointed me to a follow-up video where he announced a pivot back to the way things were. I promptly resubscribed and repledged. The scripted redo, the second video posted after his hiatus, came out this way:

That wasn’t the end, though. Content creation continued to be a struggle for Matt. After this IUPG video on WWE 2K20 (where, ironically, he ended the video on an uplifting, positive note about future content)…:

…the burnout reached its apex. The only solution was to go unscripted in 2020 to lessen the burden. I wouldn’t have that, unpledging and unsubscribing for good. I hoped for the best for him, but what he had in mind was not what I wanted.

As someone with weekly radio shows I record well in advance, and a compulsion to photograph and recap events I attend (i.e. UPLINK last year, Smooth Jazz for Scholars every normal year), I empathize with Matt’s struggle. There are times where I can’t handle the stress and want to quit. Somehow, I get through the creation process each week with the radio shows, but with the second UPLINK last month, I just couldn’t bring myself to take notes on four panels I chose to watch and adapt those notes into a recap as I did the first time. As for the radio shows, it takes at least five times as long to create, script, record, and produce each one. Yes, like I preferred Matt do, I script out my talk breaks with freedom to ad-lib occasionally. I started doing that last summer because there was a lot of information to disseminate and I didn’t want to forget anything. I feel I have enough voice over training and natural talent where I don’t always sound like I’m reading from a script. But even with all the work that goes into a show, I’ll make a mistake or forget something and need to redo a line or few. I don’t know how long my show’s run will be, but I greatly hope I don’t get burned out.

As 2020 dragged on, I assumed it was (new) business as usual for Matt, carrying on like any content creator. Other channels I unsubscribed from over small things – like mispronouncing words and phrases (some even intentionally to trigger pedants), saying “kind of” or “sort of” every other sentence, going on anti-humor tangents, and saying “at the end of the day” instead of “ultimately” or “in the end” – continue to put out content. They do just fine without my pedantry. Not Matt. On February 7 of this year, someone commented on one of my IUPG screencap Instagram posts (8/25 UPDATE: Instagram seems to have removed embedding for WordPress sites):

Whatever happened to him? The guy has completely disappeared. Even on his second channel. Along with social media.

The commenter was right. If you try to access the Cygnus Destroyer accounts on Twitter and Facebook, you’re told the pages no longer exist. Matt left up the YouTube channel for posterity, calling it simply “LJN Defender.”

He wrote this in the channel about tab:

This is the old channel for the LJN Defender and home to Innocent Until Proven Guilty. I’ve now stopped making these types of videos because I no longer enjoy making them, but you will always be able to watch my old content right here.

The last post in the community tab was 11 months ago. Looking at the comments for the post before that have me worried that I caused Matt’s demise.

Blindsided, I replied to the commenter:

Whoa, I had no idea. I quit following and supporting him early last year when he abandoned scripted videos. Sad to hear he’s disappeared from the public eye.

After visiting the channel, I wrote a follow-up:

And now I see that those videos aren’t even listed. It just stops at WWE 2K20. Well, I think I’ll resubscribe just so I can reacquaint myself with his videos. I was a diehard fan for three years and watched nearly every video he posted.

I did as I said, watching all 180 videos that Matt left up (8/25 UPDATE: two seem to have been removed) (9/19 UPDATE: another two were removed) over the past three weeks, from the evening of February 12 through this morning. (Oddly, he removed closed captioning from the remaining videos.) I even watched unscripted ones like his second anniversary video. Along the way, I noticed that some now-unlisted videos remained in the end screen. I watched one of them (9/19 UPDATE: removed). As my journey progressed, I occasionally felt wistful, knowing that the man I was watching had essentially disappeared off the face of the Earth. I also felt nostalgic for later videos, recalling what was going on in my life at the time they were published.

Wherever you are, Matt, know that you still have plenty of fans, including me, that are grateful for the seven years of content you gave us. The pedantic side of me may not like the small things from your unscripted moments, but your videos brought me joy. They were informative, enlightening, and entertaining. Thank you and God bless you.